How we score colleges

Nearly every number on EducationGuide comes from a public federal source; admitted students' GPA and test ranges come from state university systems and are labeled as such. The school pages and the free report use the same data and the same rules. This page explains those rules so you can check our work. No school pays to appear, to be picked, or to be ranked.

Which colleges are included

Public and private nonprofit colleges that award bachelor's degrees to at least 100 undergraduates, about 1,900 nationwide. Online-only campuses and graduate-only schools are left out. We are publishing school pages one state at a time, starting with Florida.

Two comparison groups: your state and the nation

School pages place each school among the colleges in its own state (“higher than 69% of Florida colleges we cover”) because that is how most families shop, and also show where it falls nationally.

The report scores every school against the same national group, so a score means the same thing whether your list mixes states or not. Each score in the report also shows the school's rank in its own state.

The two can differ. A school can be above the Florida middle on graduate earnings and below the national middle at the same time, because earnings in Florida run below the national level. Both are true; we show both.

Scores from 0 to 10

Each factor score is the school's percentile among the national group, divided by 10. A 7.0 on graduation rate means the school's rate is higher than about 70% of colleges. For cost and debt, lower is better, so a 7.0 means cheaper or less debt than about 70% of colleges.

Cost is scored at your family's income band when you give one, against what other colleges charge families at that income.

The match score

The match score (0–100) is a weighted average of the factor scores, using the weights you set. It starts with equal weights on every factor, and you can choose a preset or adjust each weight. Admission odds count only when you enter a test score or GPA, and campus fit counts only when you set a preference.

When data is missing

When a school has no reported graduation rate, earnings or debt figure, that factor counts as a neutral 5 out of 10, so a gap in the federal data neither helps nor hurts the school. The report marks those schools “Limited data.”

Schools we choose for you (“Pick schools for me” and “Also consider”) must report a graduation rate, earnings, and either an acceptance rate or a net price. The same standard decides which school pages appear in search engines. Schools you add yourself are always included.

Admission chances: reach, target, likely

We compare your GPA and SAT or ACT with the middle 50% (25th to 75th percentile) of a college's students. Likely: at or above the 75th percentile on every measure we can compare. Reach: below the 25th percentile on any measure. Target: everything in between. Colleges that admit fewer than 20% of applicants are never labeled Likely, because strong numbers alone don't predict admission there.

Which students we compare you with matters. Where a state system or university publishes the ranges of students it admitted, we use those, including GPA: all 12 Florida public universities (State University System Counselor Guide, summer and fall) and the 9 University of California campuses (GPA only; UC doesn't consider SAT or ACT). Virginia publishes GPA and test ranges of entering students at its public and private colleges (SCHEV), which we use next. Elsewhere we use federal data, which covers students who enrolled and has no GPA; we label it. The two can differ a lot: Florida State's admitted fall students had SATs of 1380–1480, while its enrolled students (federal, Fall 2024) had 1270–1410.

Florida public universities recalculate GPA from core academic courses and add weight for AP, IB, AICE, dual enrollment and honors, so their ranges are weighted; UC's GPA is weighted too (honors points capped at 8 semesters in grades 10–11). We compare a weighted range only with a weighted GPA. Virginia's colleges each report GPA as they record it, so there a GPA below the range still makes a college a reach, but a GPA above it can't by itself make a college likely; your test score has to be above the range too. Several also admit a summer-start class with lower ranges, which we show separately. When a college publishes only an average, we treat scores within 60 SAT points, 2 ACT points or 0.15 GPA points of it as in range.

Class rank (optional). If you enter a class-rank band (top 10%, top quarter, top half), each college that reports class rank in its Common Data Set (item C10) shows the share of its first-years with a rank who were in that band. It is context only and never changes reach, target or likely: many high schools no longer rank, and colleges report rank only for students who had one.

This is a comparison with published numbers, not a probability. Colleges also weigh course rigor, essays, activities, residency and intended major. Check your chances

What a family pays

“What you'd pay” is the average net price after grants and scholarships for first-time, full-time students who receive federal aid, at your income band (College Scorecard). Public colleges report it for in-state students only, so for out-of-state students we show the sticker price with out-of-state tuition. Where grants exceed the full cost, we show $0. These are averages, not quotes; each college's net price calculator gives a personal estimate.

Graduation and earnings

Graduation rate is the share of first-time, full-time students who finish within six years. Earnings are the median for former students who received federal aid, ten years after they started college. Earnings by major are for a school's graduates in that major, four years after graduating (College Scorecard field of study). Career wages are for all workers in a job, not only recent graduates (Bureau of Labor Statistics).

Cost to finish and years to pay back

These are our calculations, joining four public sources; no single source publishes them.

Cost to finish = the yearly net price at your income × the average number of years graduates took to finish. Time to finish comes from IPEDS Graduation Rates for students who entered in fall 2017 seeking a bachelor's degree: of those who finished within six years, how many finished in four, five or six. A college with fewer than 30 students in that group, or that doesn't report it, gets no estimate. Public colleges use the in-state net price; out of state, we use the sticker price.

Years to pay back = cost to finish ÷ the yearly earnings gain. The gain is graduates' median earnings minus the median earnings of high school graduates ages 25 to 34 in the college's state who are working and not in school (our calculation from Census American Community Survey 5-year microdata, 2020-2024). School pages use former students' earnings ten years after starting college; major pages use that major's graduates four years after graduating. The same idea is used by Third Way's price-to-earnings premium; we add it for every income band and every major.

Limits: figures are before taxes and loan interest, and leave out earnings given up while in school. Results over 20 years show as “more than 20 years”; where graduates don't out-earn high school graduates we say so instead of a number. Same major, other colleges compares a program's 4-year earnings with the median across the state's and the nation's covered colleges offering that major (state shown when at least three report).

Best value for your income (state pages) ranks colleges where most degrees awarded are bachelor's by the fewest years to pay back at the income you pick.

Degree pages

Each degree page joins four public sources. Graduates, 4 years out is the median across colleges of each college's median earnings for that major four years after graduating (College Scorecard, graduates who received federal aid). Ages 25-34 is our calculation from Census American Community Survey 5-year microdata (2020-2024): everyone ages 25-34 whose highest degree is a bachelor's in the matching field, working and not in school. Census fields of degree are broader than college majors; we match them with the Census Bureau's field-of-degree crosswalk, carried forward to today's major codes, and say on the page when we matched a major by hand. We publish a field only when at least 100 people in the survey hold it. When a field is smaller, we show the figure for its Census family instead (for example, all engineering majors for mining engineering), labeled as such, unless the small field's own figure (from 20 or more people) is more than 25% away from the family's, in which case we show none. Family figures never appear in page titles, questions or comparisons. Majors with no bachelor's field in the survey (graduate-only, high school and military training programs, and combined majors such as economics and computer science) show no figure.

Jobs graduates hold are the most common occupations of employed 25-34-year-olds with that field of degree (Census), with U.S. median wages and 2025-35 growth from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Who tends to enjoy this work averages O*NET's interest scores for those jobs, weighted by how many graduates hold each one. State figures need at least 3 colleges or 100 survey respondents. A degree page is indexed when at least 20 colleges report the major's earnings.

Career pages

Pay is the median annual wage for everyone in the job, nationally, by state and in metro areas (Bureau of Labor Statistics, May 2025); growth and openings are BLS projections for 2025-35. Ages 25-34 figures are our calculation from Census microdata (2020-2024) for workers with at least a high school diploma: the share holding a bachelor's or higher, their median earnings, and the fields their bachelor's degrees are in. Those fields describe what people in the job studied, not what the job requires. Required education, preparation level, skills, knowledge, work styles and interests come from O*NET 31.0 (U.S. Department of Labor), whose education shares come from small worker surveys. We build pages for jobs that usually take an associate degree or more, or where at least 30% of young workers hold a bachelor's; we index those that usually take a bachelor's or more (or where half of young workers hold one) and have Census field data.

Career Finder

The Career Finder compares your answers with what O*NET (U.S. Department of Labor) reports about each job: interest scores (realistic, investigative, artistic, social, enterprising, conventional), work setting (desk, on your feet, outdoors), contact with the public, leading others, time pressure, typical work week, freedom to make decisions, and how important math and English are. Each of these is scaled from 0 to 1. Interests you pick and priorities you choose (pay, openings, growth, helping, creativity, independence) add more the stronger the job is on them; “how much” questions add more the closer the job is to your answer. The match is the weighted average over the questions you answered (interests count most). Jobs that usually need more school than you chose are left out. Pay and growth come from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. It is a way to explore, not a test of ability or personality, and your answers never leave your browser.

What the labels mean

Degree mix. We count the undergraduate awards each college gives (IPEDS completions). If at least half are bachelor's degrees, the school has no label. From 25% to 49%: “Bachelor's & associate degrees.” Under 25%: “Mostly associate degrees” or “Mostly certificates.” Many Florida state colleges fall in the last group yet offer affordable bachelor's degrees in fields like nursing and education, so the report can still suggest them and says why.

Online campuses. When 90% or more of a campus's undergraduates take only online courses (IPEDS fall 2023 distance education), its page and data stay available, but it is left out of state college lists, best-value rankings and report suggestions: its prices and graduate earnings describe mostly working adults studying online, not students choosing a campus. Campuses where half or more study only online carry a note.

Admissions year. The newest entering class leads. Figures only available for an earlier year, such as applicant counts, are labeled with their year.

Sources and years

  • U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard (institution and field-of-study files, June 2026 release)
  • IPEDS: admissions (Fall 2023 counts), completions (2023-24), cost of attendance items (2023-24), enrollment and residence (Fall 2023)
  • Bureau of Labor Statistics: Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (May 2025); Employment Projections (2025-35)
  • Bureau of Economic Analysis regional price parities (2024); HUD Fair Market Rents (FY2027); Census American Community Survey 5-year (2024), 1-year (2024, median earnings by education) and 5-year microdata (2020-2024, earnings ages 25-34)
  • IPEDS Graduation Rates (GR2023: fall 2017 bachelor's-seeking cohort, finished in 4, 5 or 6 years)
  • State University System of Florida 2026-27 Counselor Guide (admitted students' middle-50% GPA, SAT, ACT and CLT, summer and fall)
  • University of California first-year admit data, fall 2026 (admitted students' middle-50% GPA, each campus)
  • State Council of Higher Education for Virginia, B10 First-Time Freshman Profile 2025-26 and 2026-27 (entering students' GPA, SAT and ACT percentiles)
  • IPEDS Institutional Characteristics 2025-26 (2024-25 for open admission): academic calendar, AP and prior-learning credit, ROTC, study abroad, evening and weekend classes, teacher certification, student and veteran services, students registered with disability services. IPEDS Cost survey 2024-25: application fee, first-year live-on requirement, college housing and meal plans. IPEDS directory 2024-25: each college's admissions web address
  • Common Data Set, each college's own file (2025-26, or the newest edition up to two years old; 359 colleges in 48 states and DC so far): admission factors, application deadlines and fees, early decision and early action dates, waitlist, transfer admission, high school GPA of first-year students, class sizes, faculty and student to faculty ratio, housing and Greek life, need met and merit aid. Where both the Common Data Set and IPEDS report a student to faculty ratio and they differ by more than one, we show both with their definitions. The transfer acceptance rate is admitted ÷ applied, shown only when the college reports both. We collect each file, read the values, and note any correction on the page. What the Common Data Set is and which colleges post it.
  • NOAA climate normals (1991-2020); FEMA National Risk Index; Urban Institute Education Data Portal (loan default, athletics; ODC-By); Wikidata

Each figure is stored with the year it describes. When a new federal release arrives we add a year rather than replacing one, so pages can show changes over time.

What is not included yet

State grant and scholarship amounts (such as Florida Bright Futures), college-specific merit aid outside the colleges whose Common Data Set we have read, student reviews, and campus life beyond what federal data reports.

Questions or a number that looks wrong? Email rick@educationguide.com. Browse colleges · Build a free report